Improv Challenge: Tomatoes and Peppers

I’m excited to be participating in another Improv Challenge hosted by Kristen from Frugal Antics of a Harried Homemaker (my fourth month participating)! Each month I strive to come up with something a bit more exciting or creative than the last.

So far, I’ve shared:

This month, the challenge ingredients are tomatoes and peppers.

This month is the first time that I’m not sharing the dish I had initially made for the challenge. Over the weekend, I made a curry-like dish with chicken, peppers, and tomatoes. It was good, but tasted a bit more like Mexican food than Indian food. I was a bit disappointed by this because it didn’t pair very well with naan bread. Also, it was wayyyy too spicy for me! I ate half a bowl. Even Bryan mentioned that it was spicy (his tolerance level is much higher than mine). He was able to finish, but was surprised I made it as far through the meal as I did. Because I was unsatisfied with the results, I haven’t have much inspiration to write about the experience, nor did I want to share the recipe as part of the Improv Challenge (I may share it in a week or so).

Instead, I made a last minute trip to the grocery store on Tuesday while running other errands to pick up more peppers and tomatoes so I could try again. Earlier in the day, I had been reading a blog post series on Chiles at MJ’s Kitchen. The posts were very informative, explaining that “the green chile pepper [is] called by many names – New Mexico chile, Anaheim pepper, California chile, Hatch, Big Jim, Rio Grande and Sandia – to name a few” (MJ’s Kitchen). I’d never heard it called California pepper, Big Jim, Rio Grande or Sandia! I was even a bit skeptical that an Anaheim pepper would be the same, though I’ve heard the peppers called by that name before.

Reminiscing about the amazing food in the Southwest US. I wanted green chiles afterwards, but that’s not something that’s regularly sold around here. In fact, the only Hatch Chiles I’ve seen are dried red chiles sold at specialty stores with a fairly high price tag. It’s always good, but not quite the same as green chiles.

Very much to my surprise, there was a large basket of “Anaheim Peppers” at the grocery store this week. I had to have them. The price was also surprisingly reasonable. Here’s hoping that they will start to carry these chile peppers regularly!

I’ve never really cooked with green chiles. My experience with them has mostly been meals someone else has cooked or take-out. So, for this Improv Challenge, I’m sharing one of Bryan’s recipes that I’ve adapted. This is one of the few things he would cook for me when we first met!

Green Chile Pepper and Tomato Soup

Adapted from Bryan’s recipe (I think he said he learned this from his family?)


  • 500 grams lean (or extra lean) ground beef – approximate cost $5.50
  • 10 fresh green chile peppers (New Mexico chile, Anaheim pepper, California chile, Hatch chile, Big Jim chile, Rio Grandechile or Sandia chile) – approximate cost $3.50
  • 2 cloves garlic, minced – approximate cost $0.20
  • 1 can diced tomatoes – approximate cost $1.25
  • 1 teaspoon olive oil – approximate cost $0.10
  • 1 teaspoon sea salt – approximate cost $0.05
  • 1/2 cup water


  1. Roast the chile peppers, making sure all sides are roasted (so the skins will peel away easily later).
  2. Set the roasted chile peppers in the fridge to cool.
  3. Remove the cooled chile peppers from the fridge.
  4. Roll each of the chile peppers to loosen the seeds.
  5. Cut off the tops of the chile peppers.
  6. Pour out as many seeds as possible.
    1. If you want the soup spicy, reserve a few of the seeds.
    2. If you want the soup mild, gently wash the inside of the peppers with cold water to remove the remaining seeds.
  7. Wash your hands very well with lots of soap and avoid rubbing your eyes for a while to ensure the chile peppers will not burn you.
  8. Peel the roasted skin away from the chile pepper.
  9. Discard the skin.
  10. Dice the chile peppers.
  11. Heat the olive oil over medium-high heat in a large pot.
  12. Add the garlic and cook until fragrant.
  13. Add the ground beef.
  14. Break the beef into pieces using a wooden spoon.
  15. Brown the beef (there shouldn’t be any more pink).
  16. Add the chile peppers.
  17. Mix well.
  18. Add the diced tomatoes (as well as the liquid from the can).
  19. Mix well.
  20. Add half cup water (the beef mixture should be just covered by the liquid.
  21. Bring to a boil.
  22. Add the sea salt.
  23. Taste the broth and add more salt if necessary.
  24. Remove from heat.
  25. Serve hot in soup bowls.

Makes 4 servings (approximate cost: $2.65 per serving).

Leave a comment


  1. Amber – You just made a modified Green Chile Stew – a classic New Mexican dish! Great job! Thanks for the wonderful shoutout! It’s obvious that you enjoyed the series and turned around and did something with your new found knowledge! Your roasted chiles are perfect and what gorgeous chiles – BTW. What a way to tackle this challenge!! I can smell that stew from here! Great post!

    • Thanks MJ! I truly enjoyed your series on chiles. I’m so glad to have found green chiles and hope the store will continue to carry them.

  2. What a nice recipe for the challenge Amber. I would have made a Hungarian specialty called Lecso (pronounced lecho). It has tomatoes, peppers and some potatoes and sausage.

    • Thanks Eva! Lecso sounds very interesting! Is it a soup as well? Do you have a recipe for it on your blog?

  3. Oh! You roasted your own chiles?! That’s awesome.
    Can’t wait for our weather to cool down so I can start cooking soups again…

    • Thanks Melody! Roasting the chiles is, surprisingly, not as bad as it sounds. Just turn on the broiler and stick the chiles in the oven. Turn them when the skin begins to blacken until all sides are cook. And voila! Roasted chiles.

  4. Your recipe looks amazing! I love anaheim peppers, especially roasted! I can’t wait to try your recipe!! What a great choice!

  5. Your soup sounds wonderful and it’s great that you took a second shot at cooking with the required ingredients, you have a winning recipe.

    If you haven’t already, I’d love for you to check out my Improv Cooking Challenge entry: French Fries Hash Browns.

    Cook Lisa Cook

  6. Amber, this sounds right up my alley! Can you send me a bowl?

    I have never roasted my own peppers like that, but it does cross my mind. The Hubby is not into peppers or really spicy foods, so I have to compromise a little.

    ICC #8

    • Sorry, all gone.

      The Anahiem chile peppers aren’t too spicy. You might be able to convince him to try it!

  7. That’s too bad about your first recipe, but this soup looks really good!

    • Yeah, but thankfully Bryan likes it, so the food will be enjoyed, just not by me. Thanks! It was very good. 🙂

  8. Great challenge! 🙂 I love a little spice but not too much 🙂 LOL My name is Cindy and I blog over at I wanted to invite you to link up your recipe at our Gluten Free Fridays Recipe Link up party! It happens every Friday and we’d love to have you join us with some of your awesome recipes! You can find this week’s link up here:
    Thanks, Cindy

  9. I love this recipe and it occurs to me that I shouldn’t be reading through everyone’s posts before I eat breakfast. Can’t stop drooling. I would love a buffet with all the dishes from this month’s challenge but I would start with a bowl of your chilli!

    • There was a fantastic selection in this month’s challenge! I wish I could sample everything as well!

  10. Too bad about your first dish, but this soup sounds wonderful, so I guess it all worked out for the good. It looks fantastic!

    • Yep, it all worked out! Bryan really enjoys the first dish, so it wasn’t a complete disaster. Just too spicy for my tastes.

  11. Amber…..your soup looks luscious….what a beautiful, rich broth! Peppers and tomatoes are a pretty good pairing and I’m glad you persisted in finding the perfect recipe for them!

  12. MMmmmmm….your soup looks irresistible! And it’s one my hubby would enjoy, too. Plus it actually feels like soup weather might arrive here soon 🙂

    • Thanks Liz! I actually really enjoy soups in the summer. Yes, I realize it’s hot outside, but light soups are nice during the summer months (stews and chowders are winter foods, in my opinion).

  1. Five Favourites for Friday « The Cook's Sister
  2. From my cookbook collection: Chicken Jalfrezi « The Cook's Sister
  3. Improv Challenge: Zucchini and Brown Sugar « The Cook's Sister
  4. Spicy, Slow-Cooked Beef Chili « The Cook's Sister
  5. Improv Challenge: Chocolate and Marshmallows « The Cook's Sister
  6. Improv Challenge: Bananas and Nutmeg « The Cook's Sister
  7. Piparkakut (Finnish Gingerbread) Cookies | The Cook's Sister
  8. Improv Challenge: Shepherd’s Pie | The Cook's Sister
  9. Improv Challenge: Cinnamon and Sugar (Strawberry Cobbler) | The Cook's Sister
  10. Second Blogiversary | The Cook's Sister
  11. Improv Challenge: Fish and Chips (Fried Fish-Shaped Chips) | The Cook's Sister
  12. Improv Challenge: Peaches and Herbs (Pork Chops with a Peach and Sage Glaze) | The Cook's Sister
  13. Bryan’s Mom’s Green Chile Chicken Enchilada Casserole | The Cook's Sister

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: